This year marks 250 years since the start of the American Revolution—a moment often remembered as a bold fight for freedom and a defining step toward democracy. But what if that founding moment didn’t just give the United States its ideals—what if it also planted the seeds of its deepest struggles?
The Revolution was not only a break from monarchy; it was an embrace of resistance as a civic virtue. That legacy still shapes American life in ways both powerful and perilous. Extreme individualism, the outlaw hero, a fascination with guns and violence, and enduring racial inequalities may not betray the Revolution’s ideals—they may be part of them.
Canada chose gradual reform, the United States chose rebellion. Revolution forged the republic. But 250 years on, can the republic evolve beyond rebellion? Or has defiance hardened into a reflex—one that undermines the very democracy the Revolution set out to secure?
How the American Revolution Shaped a Culture of Individualism, Violence, and Distrust
Few national stories are as celebrated—or as sacred—as the American Revolution. It’s taught in schools, mythologized in movies, and honored in public life as the moment Americans stood up to tyranny and built a republic on freedom, representation, and individual rights. The Founding Fathers are treated like secular saints, and the Declaration of Independence is practically scripture. So to question the Revolution’s virtue can feel close to heresy.
But in today’s fractured America—with its deep political divides, distrust of government, crisis of civic life, and ongoing struggles with racism and violence—more people are starting to ask whether the Revolution really set the country on the right course.
One of the most provocative voices raising this question is New Yorker writer Adam Gopnik. Canadian by birth and temperamentally moderate, Gopnik has dared to ask: Was the American Revolution a mistake?
He’s not longing for monarchy or arguing against independence. He’s asking something subtler: Did the path the United States took—through revolution rather than reform—set in motion a culture defined by extreme individualism, a romantic view of violence, deep suspicion of authority, and a racially exclusive vision of citizenship?
Canada, by contrast, stayed in the British Empire and transitioned slowly to self-rule. That path, Gopnik suggests, helped foster a more moderate, civic-minded, and pluralistic society.
What makes his argument powerful isn’t that it attacks liberty—it challenges the idea that liberty has to come from rupture. And at a time when many of the Revolution’s ideals feel fragile or hollowed out, it’s worth asking whether its founding methods—not just its message—have shaped the problems Americans face today.
Here, I take up Gopnik’s provocation and explore it from several angles: by looking at how revolution has shaped American political culture, contrasting the U.S. and Canadian paths to nationhood, examining how founding myths continue to shape ideas about race, violence, and freedom—and asking whether America can build a more stable civic life if it were to reconsider its revolutionary inheritance.
Gopnik’s Core Argument
Adam Gopnik doesn’t reject the ideals of the American Revolution—liberty, democracy, civic participation—but he questions the way they were achieved and what that path set in motion. He argues that while the Revolution secured independence, it also left behind a lasting mindset: a glorification of rebellion, deep distrust of government, and a belief that freedom means resisting authority rather than building common ground.
As a Canadian, Gopnik brings a different lens. He suggests that America’s break from Britain helped shape a political culture that favors individual autonomy over collective responsibility and moral certainty over compromise. The Revolution, in his view, didn’t just reject tyranny—it built a national identity around the rebel, a figure who resists power even when that power is democratic.
Canada, by contrast, avoided violent rupture. It gained independence gradually, through negotiation and constitutional reform. This, Gopnik argues, fostered a more moderate and cooperative political culture—one less defined by confrontation and more by civic trust and institutional legitimacy.
He doesn’t ignore Canada’s flaws—its treatment of its First Peoples, for example—but he believes its slow path to self-rule avoided hardwiring rebellion and suspicion into the national psyche. As a result, Canadians may be better equipped to work through difference, build consensus, and trust their institutions.
Gopnik’s provocative claim is this: what many Americans see as their founding glory may also be the root of their country’s enduring dysfunctions. Gun culture, tax resistance, outlaw mythology, and racial exclusion are, in his view, not historical accidents but part of the Revolution’s legacy. The Revolution didn’t just create a country—it shaped how Americans still think about power, freedom, and one another.
Rather than rejecting the Revolution, Gopnik urges a reckoning with its deeper meanings. In the name of liberty, did America also plant the seeds of division? And can the country build a more stable civic life without confronting the mythology at its core?
The Philosophy of Revolution
To assess Gopnik’s critique of the American Revolution, it helps to step back and ask: What is a revolution? Is it a necessary force for progress—or a dangerous rupture that breeds violence and instability along with idealism? These aren’t just historical questions; they go to the heart of how societies understand legitimacy, time, and political change.
For much of history, revolutions were seen as cycles, not ruptures. The term itself—revolutio—meant a return, as monarchies gave way to tyranny and then circled back again. It wasn’t until the late 18th century that revolution came to mean a break with the past and a leap toward a new future. The American and French Revolutions helped redefine history as a forward-driving force, not a repetitive loop.
This shift carried profound philosophical weight. Thinkers like Kant and Hegel saw revolution as a world-historical event that advanced human freedom and reason. Marx built on this, imagining revolution as the engine of class struggle and utopia. But others, like Edmund Burke, saw danger in overthrowing traditions in pursuit of abstract ideals. Hannah Arendt later praised the American Revolution for its focus on political founding, but warned of the perils of glorifying rupture itself.
The German historian Reinhart Koselleck offers a powerful lens for understanding this tension. In Critique and Crisis, he argued that Enlightenment thinkers armed themselves with new moral languages—“progress,” “humanity,” “history”—to delegitimize existing regimes. These abstract ideals became tools of critique without clear responsibility, inspiring revolutions whose leaders often struggled to govern once in power.
Koselleck also showed that our very sense of time changed in the revolutionary age. The past no longer guided the present; instead, history became “temporalized”—reimagined as a force driving toward redemption or justice. This mindset, whether liberal, Marxist, or nationalist, justified violence as historically necessary—even though history remained contingent, shaped by structures but open to chance and rupture.
Dan Edelstein’s new book, The Revolution to Come, deepens this insight. He shows how modern revolutions are animated by the belief that a new political order can redeem the failings of the old one—and how this belief, far from liberating, can bind societies to cycles of expectation, disappointment, and renewed upheaval.
Gopnik’s critique echoes this broader skepticism. America didn’t just win independence—it enshrined rebellion as a civic virtue. That revolutionary mindset didn’t end in 1783. It helped legitimize later defiance: from the Confederacy to gun rights absolutism, from anti-tax movements to libertarian resistance to public health.
By contrast, Canada’s gradual path to independence fostered a very different political culture: less utopian, more procedural; less romantic about freedom, more focused on public order. Its evolution wasn’t free of injustice, but it wasn’t built on a myth of permanent rupture.
Gopnik’s argument, then, isn’t just political—it’s philosophical. It raises a deeper question: What happens when a nation is born not just through revolution, but around the idea that revolution is redemptive? Can such a society ever fully embrace compromise, restraint, or civic trust? Or does the mythology of rupture keep pulling it toward polarization and unrest?
American Legacies: Individualism, Violence, Race
If the American Revolution celebrated rupture and resistance, what legacies did it leave behind? Adam Gopnik argues that several core features of American life—radical individualism, a tolerance for violence, and persistent racial inequality—can be traced to the Revolution’s political culture and moral psychology. These weren’t later distortions, he suggests, but part of the founding logic.
Radical Individualism: The Citizen as Rebel
The American Revolution helped cement the ideal of the autonomous individual: self-reliant, rights-bearing, and deeply wary of government. Liberty was framed less as shared self-rule and more as freedom from interference—especially from centralized authority.
This ideal became a national ethos. From the frontier settler and cowboy to the suburban homeowner, American culture celebrates those who resist outside control. But this celebration of independence can undermine collective responsibility. Resistance to taxes, public healthcare, environmental policy—even pandemic measures—reflects a deeper distrust of “big government” and a reluctance to act for the common good.
The Romance of Violence: Revolution as Redemption
The Revolution also tied American identity to armed resistance. The gun became more than a tool—it became a symbol of citizenship and freedom. The belief that violence can redeem or restore liberty is deeply woven into American mythology, from Jefferson’s call to “refresh the tree of liberty” to modern action films and armed protests.
This legacy shapes U.S. politics and public life in real ways. Gun violence, mass shootings, and resistance to reform persist not just because of policy failures but because of a cultural script: that freedom must be defended—if necessary, by force.
Racial Exclusion: The Paradox of Revolutionary Freedom
The Revolution’s commitment to liberty coexisted with the defense of slavery. As historians like Gerald Horne and David Waldstreicher argue, some colonial elites feared British moves against slavery and saw independence as a way to protect white supremacy.
The Constitution preserved slavery in coded language. Voting rights were limited to white male property owners. Indigenous peoples were treated as obstacles to expansion. The very idea of “the people” was racially bounded.
In Gopnik’s view, the Revolution fostered a zero-sum view of power: liberty for some, exclusion for others. Later efforts to expand rights—from Reconstruction to the Civil Rights Movement—have had to confront a founding myth that treated freedom as something to possess, not to share.
The Double Legacy
The American Revolution left behind both soaring ideals and stubborn problems. It inspired democratic movements across the world. But it also embedded cultural patterns—radical individualism, glorified violence, racial hierarchy—that still shape American life.
Gopnik’s point isn’t that these outcomes were inevitable. Rather, the Revolution’s framework made them likely. By baking rebellion, suspicion, and exclusion into the nation’s foundation, it left Americans with a hard question: Can a republic born of revolt ever fully embrace civic peace and pluralism?
The Canadian Countermodel
If the American Revolution embedded rebellion, individualism, and distrust into the nation’s DNA, Adam Gopnik offers Canada as a telling contrast: a country that chose gradual reform over violent rupture. By comparing these two North American paths to nationhood, Gopnik invites us to ask not just what revolution achieved—but what it may have cost.
Where the United States broke away through war and ideological declaration, Canada stayed in the British Empire, gradually gaining autonomy through negotiation and parliamentary reform. Its founding moment wasn’t a revolution but the 1867 British North America Act. Full independence came later, and incrementally. As a result, Canada’s political culture prizes continuity, not rupture.
Trust Over Suspicion
Without a revolution, Canada didn’t frame its identity around resisting government. Instead, it built a civic culture that leans on public institutions—healthcare, social services, parliamentary democracy—and sees government less as a threat and more as a partner in the common good.
This hasn’t meant perfect governance or inclusion. But it’s shaped a political style more oriented toward collective wellbeing and legal order than personal liberty at all costs. There is no Canadian equivalent to the Second Amendment, and no national myth equating freedom with private arsenals.
That difference matters. Canada’s parliamentary system encourages compromise and party discipline, limiting gridlock and polarizing culture wars. Americans often see politics as moral combat; Canadians tend to see it as negotiation.
Pluralism Over Assimilation
Canada has its own colonial and racist past, including harm done to Indigenous communities. But in the postwar period, especially under Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau, it officially embraced multiculturalism—seeking to accommodate diversity within a civic framework.
This model arose in part to manage French-English tensions but had wider impact: a pluralistic national identity that’s layered, not singular. Where America has struggled with a universal creed often applied unequally, Canada has leaned into differentiated belonging.
The result? Less moral absolutism. Canadians, while politically active, are less likely to frame political conflict as existential. Without a founding myth built on rebellion, civic belonging feels less like a loyalty test and more like participation in a shared project.
No Cult of the Outlaw
Gopnik also lays bare a key symbolic difference: Americans glorify rebellious heroes—cowboys, gangsters, tech disruptors. Canadians don’t. Their national stories spotlight public servants, mediators, and team players.
Even in pop culture, Canadian narratives tend toward humility and irony, not swagger. This shapes how citizens see law and power. Government isn’t the enemy. The law isn’t tyranny. While that mindset can tilt toward complacency, it helps avoid the romanticization of resistance that, in the United States, can turn into insurrectionism.
No Utopia—But a Different Ethos
Gopnik doesn’t idealize Canada. He acknowledges its injustices and failures. But his point isn’t that Canada is innocent—it’s that it’s oriented differently.
By avoiding revolution, Canada didn’t sanctify violence, rupture, or rebellion as civic virtues. Instead, it built a political culture more centered on continuity, compromise, and pluralism.
The comparison is meant to complicate America’s triumphalist story. Maybe a nation can be freer without obsessing over freedom. Maybe public life is healthier when it’s less heroic. And maybe, sometimes, not having a revolution is the radical choice.
Voices from the Margins: Loyalists, Indigenous Peoples, and the Enslaved
To fully understand the legacy of the American Revolution, we must look beyond its celebrated leaders to those left out or harmed by its aftermath. While the Revolution is often framed as a heroic struggle for liberty, that narrative hides the realities faced by those for whom independence meant exclusion, displacement, or betrayal.
By centering the experiences of Loyalists, Indigenous peoples, and the enslaved, we gain a clearer view of what the Revolution truly meant—and what its lofty ideals often obscured.
Loyalists: Expelled from the New Nation
Over 60,000 colonists remained loyal to Britain during the Revolution. They came from many backgrounds—wealthy merchants, religious minorities, enslaved people promised freedom by the British, Indigenous allies, and others wary of rebellion.
After the war, many faced violence, property confiscation, and exile. Thousands resettled in Canada, helping to shape its early identity. Their fate underscores a key point: the American Revolution did not tolerate pluralism. Patriotism demanded conformity. Dissenters were driven out.
Indigenous Peoples: Sacrificed to Expansion
For many Native nations, the American Revolution was not a movement for freedom but a disaster. As historian Colin Calloway has shown in works like The American Revolution in Indian Country, many Indigenous groups saw the British—not the rebelling colonists—as the better bet for protecting their lands and treaties. Native leaders hoped that supporting the Crown might restrain settler expansion and preserve their autonomy.
But the 1783 Treaty of Paris shattered those hopes. Signed without Indigenous input, it ceded vast Native territories to the new United States, treating sovereign nations as if they were empty land. The result was a wave of warfare, dispossession, and forced migration. The young republic regarded Native peoples not as partners but as obstacles to its vision of continental expansion.
As Theda Perdue and Gregory Evans Dowd have documented, the new United States quickly moved to assert control through military campaigns, treaty violations, and land grabs. The Revolution’s language of liberty was never meant for the continent’s original inhabitants. Their political systems were ignored, their sovereignty erased.
In contrast, Canada’s path to independence—while also rooted in settler colonialism—unfolded without the ideological rupture of revolution. As scholars like Barbara Graymont have noted, this difference initially allowed for more formalized, if still deeply unequal, treaty processes. Canada’s colonial governments were less driven by a sense of manifest destiny or revolutionary entitlement, which contributed to a comparatively slower pace of violent displacement—though not to its absence.
The Revolution’s greatest irony may be here: a war for self-rule systematically denied that same right to the Indigenous nations who had long governed themselves. As Calloway and others remind us, the American founding did not just exclude Native voices—it actively silenced and displaced them, laying the groundwork for centuries of erasure and resistance.
Enslaved People: Freedom for Whom?
The Revolution’s greatest contradiction was its embrace of liberty alongside the preservation of slavery. Though the Declaration of Independence spoke of equality, the founders largely excluded the enslaved. Many were slaveholders themselves, and the Constitution later enshrined protections for slavery.
In contrast, the British offered freedom to enslaved people who joined their ranks. Thousands responded, forming Black Loyalist communities in Canada and other British territories. Britain’s earlier moves toward abolition—such as the Somerset ruling (1772) and the Slavery Abolition Act (1833)—meant that freedom often came sooner, and with less racial violence, than in the U.S. South.
Some American revolutionaries even feared British emancipation efforts, like Lord Dunmore’s 1775 proclamation offering freedom to slaves willing to fight. Far from opposing slavery, parts of the Revolution were driven by a desire to preserve it.
A Republic for Whom?
The American Republic was founded on high ideals—but also on exclusions. Loyalists fled, Indigenous nations were displaced, and Southern slavery was entrenched. Citizenship was defined narrowly—by race, property, and political loyalty.
Gopnik’s comparison with Canada becomes especially sharp here. Though far from free of injustice, Canada’s more gradual path to independence didn’t canonize rebellion or elevate exclusion as a civic virtue. That has, in some ways, allowed greater space to acknowledge historic wrongs.
In the United States, by contrast, the Revolution remains sacred. To question its legacy is often seen as unpatriotic. That reverence can make it harder to fully confront the injustices built into the nation’s founding—and harder still to imagine a more inclusive democracy.
Cultural Mythologies and the Outlaw Hero
Adam Gopnik’s critique of the American Revolution isn’t limited to its politics—it extends to the cultural imagination. He argues that the Revolution didn’t just create a republic; it created a mythology. At its center is the figure of the rebellious individual—the “outlaw hero”—who resists authority not only when it’s unjust but as a matter of principle.
The American Revolution cast the rebel as a moral archetype. Over time, this figure reappeared in many guises:
The frontiersman beyond the law’s reach
The cowboy with his own code
The gangster who rises through defiance
The vigilante dispensing justice
The tech disruptor who refuses to play by the rules
Even when these figures are morally gray or criminal, they’re often seen as embodiments of individualism. Their defiance is their virtue. This sensibility has shaped American culture—from Westerns to Silicon Valley to political movements that glorify the outsider over the institution.
Politics as Performance of Rebellion
This ethos shapes American politics too. Leaders on both the left and right often cast themselves as insurgents. Donald Trump’s “drain the swamp” message echoes this mythology, but so do progressive calls to “resist” the establishment. In both cases, legitimacy comes not from governance but from opposition.
The result is a political culture that prizes disruption over deliberation. Government is seen less as a tool for the common good than as a threat to personal freedom. Even public health guidelines or tax policies can be recast as tyrannical overreach.
Canada’s Counter-Narrative: The Quiet Hero
Gopnik contrasts this with Canada’s more restrained national story. Without a revolutionary founding, Canada did not sanctify rebellion. Its heroes are typically public servants, mediators, or quiet reformers. The Mountie enforces the law, not frontier justice. Canadian culture prizes irony over grandiosity, cooperation over defiance.
This cultural orientation supports a more collaborative relationship with government. Canadians are more likely to accept regulation as part of civic life and less likely to romanticize violent resistance. While Canada is not without injustice or extremism, its founding narrative doesn’t celebrate rupture or rebellion.
The Price of the Myth
Gopnik acknowledges the creative energy of American individualism. But he warns that elevating the rebel above all else undermines the habits democracy depends on: trust, compromise, and procedural order. When dissent becomes a civic religion, governance starts to seem like betrayal.
The outlaw hero myth makes consensus look weak and collaboration look corrupt. It valorizes disruption and stigmatizes the slow, necessary work of collective decision-making. In this way, the Revolution’s mythic legacy shapes not just policy but the emotional texture of American public life.
A Legacy That Still Shapes the Present
Gopnik’s rethinking of the American Revolution is more than historical critique—it’s a diagnosis of contemporary dysfunction. Today’s polarization, distrust, and democratic backsliding aren’t simply deviations from founding ideals. In Gopnik’s view, they’re the logical outgrowth of a political culture that sacralized resistance and suspicion of power.
The American story celebrates liberty as resistance. But in doing so, it struggles to imagine freedom as something shared, structured, and sustained by institutions. The result: a democracy always on the verge of disillusionment, where the impulse to rebel often outweighs the will to govern.
In contrast, Canada’s evolutionary path has produced a more moderate political culture—one better able to absorb difference, negotiate solutions, and maintain civic peace without mythologizing defiance.
Gopnik invites us to reconsider what kind of stories a democracy should tell. If rebellion is always heroic, institutions will always seem suspect. But if civic life is understood as a shared responsibility, then consensus, not confrontation, becomes the true measure of freedom.
The Gun as Revolutionary Symbol
Few legacies of the American Revolution are more enduring—or more fraught—than the country’s relationship with guns. The Second Amendment, born from fears of standing armies and government tyranny, elevated the firearm into a civic symbol. In this mythology, the gun is not just a weapon but a marker of independence, self-reliance, and resistance to authority.
The costs have been staggering. The United States suffers unparalleled levels of gun violence and mass shootings. Yet even modest efforts at regulation often falter—not just due to lobbying, but because such efforts are framed as threats to liberty itself. Gopnik argues this mindset is a direct inheritance of the Revolution: a culture that sees armed resistance as the ultimate defense of freedom.
The January 6, 2021 Insurrection and the Mythic Afterlife of 1776
This myth was on full display during the January 6, 2021 Capitol insurrection. For many participants, it was not rebellion but patriotism—an attempt to "restore" the republic. Symbols of the Revolution were everywhere: colonial flags, “Don’t Tread on Me” banners, appeals to 1776. The event was less a rejection of American ideals than a distorted reenactment of them.
The irony is grim. What began as resistance to empire has been repurposed as resistance to democracy itself—to pluralism, to procedure, to the peaceful transfer of power. Gopnik doesn’t blame the Revolution for this directly. But he argues that its moral language and habits of thought—glorifying defiance, distrusting institutions—make it harder for Americans to adapt to the realities of democratic life in a diverse society.
What Kind of Civic Culture Do We Want?
Gopnik’s question isn’t historical, but imaginative: must a nation born in revolution remain forever revolutionary? Can Americans shift from celebrating rebellion to sustaining democracy—not by abandoning liberty, but by reimagining it as shared responsibility?
This is not a call to renounce the founding, but to grow beyond its most rigid tropes. To value not just rupture, but repair. Not just heroism, but cooperation. Not just freedom from, but freedom with.
Other nations offer alternatives. Canada achieved independence without revolution and built its civic identity around negotiation, not resistance. Gopnik doesn’t idealize Canada, but he does suggest its evolutionary path left more room for reflection, reform, and pluralism.
Civic Identity Without Rebellion
In the United States, the Revolution is often treated as sacred—a singular event that permanently defines the meaning of liberty. But Gopnik urges a more critical lens: What kind of political culture did the Revolution actually create? What habits did it reward? And what alternatives did it obscure?
The answers are sobering. The founding enshrined deep mistrust of government, idealized individual righteousness, romanticized rupture, and restricted belonging to a narrow elite. Today, those habits fuel polarization, disinformation, political violence, and civic fragmentation.
By contrast, Canada’s less mythologized founding has enabled a more flexible civic imagination—one not bound to reenacting 1776. That difference, Gopnik suggests, may explain why Canadians are more likely to treat politics as a process, not a moral showdown.
Reimagining the American Story
To imagine a civic identity without rebellion is not to erase the past but to rethink its uses. It means learning from the Revolution’s contradictions as well as its ideals—and recognizing that democracy depends not just on moments of defiance but on the patient, often unglamorous work of governance.
Gopnik’s critique is not anti-American. It is a call to fulfill the country’s democratic promise by outgrowing its adolescent attachment to heroic resistance. The next revolution, he suggests, may not come with muskets or manifestos. It may begin with something quieter: the willingness to treat fellow citizens not as enemies or threats, but as partners in the unfinished work of democracy.

You only see stuff like this when a Republican is president — there were many articles like this under Dubya and especially Trump, but none under Obama or Biden.
Heck, Obamulans on DemocraticUnderground claimed Republicans were literally treasonous. They were sure American nationalists when it suited them.
Gopnik is Canadian? Of course he’d disdain the Revolution. He’s a Loyalist.